Navigating the complexities of an unexpected pregnancy can often bring couples closer or, on the contrary, highlight underlying tension and mistrust. For the man in question, what began as a commitment to step up fatherhood and embrace a new life with his fiancee Vivian took a dark turn when he faced a disturbing “test of fidelity” orchestrated by her and her best friend Carly. This drastic step not only questioned the sincerity of their relationship but also revealed deeper issues of trust and communication between them.
A scenario described by a Reddit user reveals a web of emotional manipulation and the profound impact such actions can have on personal relationships. Being tested in such a traumatic and fraudulent way, especially over something as sensitive as abortion, has significant psychological consequences. It forces the original poster (OP) to rethink not only his relationship with Vivian but also his future and the dynamics of their upcoming parenthood.
Even though the child was not intended, the man did the right thing and proposed to his partner after she became pregnant. When his fiancee and a friend “tested” his dedication and loyalty in the most painful way, he began to regret his proposal.
The 26-year-old posted a question about his situation on Reddit’s “AITA” subreddit. After five years of dating, the Redditor revealed that he and his 28-year-old fiancee Vivian found out she was expecting a baby soon after he proposed.
Despite the fact that the pregnancy was not intended, the couple was happy. The idea that he should get married while his fiancée was pregnant apparently appeased her parents, who were furious that he had gotten her pregnant before they were even married.
Although the original poster (OP) admitted that his potential in-laws are Christians, he also revealed that they do not force their religion on others. Four days before her fiance published his story, Vivian was thirteen weeks pregnant. After work, he went straight to their shared apartment.
He discovered 29-year-old Carly, Vivian’s best friend, sitting on the couch looking upset. He asked where his fiancee was and if everything was okay as it was unusual for her to be depressed. According to the acquaintance, he continued into the couple’s master bathroom, where Vivian was.
However, he saw Carly following him, which he dismissed as strange. when OP knocked and asked permission to enter, his fiancee said ok. But when he opened the door, he saw her standing over the toilet, looking at him with tears in her eyes. Redditor commented:
“I immediately asked her what was going on and Vivian snorted and told me she had miscarried and motioned for me to look in the bathroom.
The water in the toilet bowl had a reddish tint and appeared to contain an embryo.
He looked away and began to cry and sob, then reached out and grabbed his companion, wrapped his arms around her, and sobbed into her shoulder.
He looked up to see Carly in the bathroom mirror standing by the door. It looked like she was using her phone to record anything or take pictures. The OP let Vivian go and rudely asked her friend what she was doing.
Vivian cut her off before Carly could find the right answer, leaving her stuttering.
Reddit Member’s Fiancé Admits She Didn’t Miscarry; rather, it was a test to see how he would react if she actually lost their child. It took OP a while to figure out how those two friends could treat him so cruelly.
When his partner tried to touch his face, he finally pulled away from her and pushed her hands away. At that moment, the sad man did not want her to touch him or come near him. He tried to leave the restroom and both his fiancee and Carly tried to stop him but he pushed past them to get to his bedroom.
After stuffing his clothes into his bag, the OP grabbed his keys and headed for the apartment door. When Vivian finally caught up to him at the door, she begged him to stay and discuss what had happened, but he refused, saying that he needed time to think things over on his own.
Although she didn’t pressure him to stay, his fiancee looked sad to be leaving. He ended up staying with his 26-year-old friend Josh. After telling Josh what happened, the friend said that Vivian had done something wrong and that she could stay as long as she wanted.
OP acknowledged that he acted immaturely when he ignored his fiancee’s calls and texts for the next two days, except to let her know he was safe. Once he was stabilized, he asked Vivian to speak. She claimed she was afraid he wouldn’t want the baby, so she decided to test him.
His girlfriend revealed that she is worried that he is taking care of her and the child so that he will not be labeled as a childless man.
Before stating that he really wanted to be the father of their child and that he understood her anxieties, the OP
“In the end, I decided to stay with Vivian, but on the condition that we call off the wedding (sic) until after the baby is born and we do couple’s counseling.”
Vivian left Josh’s apartment after accepting his demands. OP thought everything was resolved and intended to come home soon, but Carly texted him an hour after his fiancee left, accusing him of pressuring Vivian to have a child out of wedlock.
“This incident should be a blessing in disguise for you to see who he really is.
Carly said he was offended by her texts and understood that was not his future in-laws’ wishes. Vivian’s friend had to be blocked by the OP due to extreme harassment. He clarified that he contacted Reddit members to ask if they believed the condition he was placing on his fiancee was wrong.
Someone commented, “Huge NTA” and quoted the paragraph where the OP said that Vivian tested him because she thought he wouldn’t want the baby. And why did Carly feel the need to document it?”
“I think she’s calling it a ‘test’ to try and minimize the damage done. I’ll bet you money they thought the prank was funny. Just trying to justify her cruelty.. ( sic),” said another reader.
Someone else was adamant in her advice, “NTA Never marry this woman. She’s crazy and so is her boyfriend.”
“NTA. However, I believe that continuing to live with her is a serious mistake. And I’ll explain why. You can’t write [expletive] off as an isolated incident when someone does it.
Like it or not, it’s a reflection of who he is. It says a lot about her character to be so harsh on the man she claims to love without even trying to connect, a Reddit member wrote.
“This incident should be a blessing in disguise for you to see who he really is,” the speaker continued. You will only be responsible for yourself if you stay with her. because she has already revealed her identity to you. All you do is refuse to see it. You also mentioned her friend’s recording. I’m curious about her reasoning. When the time comes, agree on a care plan and co-parent in harmony. You wouldn’t want to spend your life as a companion with someone like that.”
Most people seemed to agree that the OP was right to postpone the wedding day, and he wasn’t wrong. Several readers thought OP’s fiancee was not someone he should start living with, even though he suggested couples counseling.
In closing, the harrowing experience described by a Reddit user underscores the complex and often tumultuous dynamics that can occur in personal relationships, especially when trust is severely tested by fraudulent “tests” or manipulations. The decision by the original poster’s fiancee and her boyfriend to stage a fake abortion as a way to measure their commitment not only eroded trust, but also highlighted the potential emotional vulnerability and insecurity underlying their relationship.
Reaction from the Reddit community overwhelmingly supported the original poster’s decision to postpone marriage and seek couples counseling, reflecting a broader consensus that relationships deeply affected by such serious violations require careful evaluation and professional intervention to heal and restore trust, if at all possible. Additionally, this incident serves as a critical reminder of the importance of communication and honesty in a partnership and highlights that testing a partner’s loyalty in manipulative ways can cause irreparable damage to a relationship.
The original poster’s approach to dealing with the aftermath—prioritizing space, setting the conditions for the relationship to continue, and engaging in couples therapy—ultimately offers a model for dealing with serious relationship issues with a focus on healing and understanding, albeit with the necessary caution. the suffering he endured. This case not only highlights individual resilience but also the need for emotional honesty and the risk of undermining trust in intimate relationships.