Is it Unjust of Me to Evict My Daughter-in-Law and Grandson from My Residence Based on What I Saw?

In times of grief and upheaval, families often come together to support each other. But the situation described in the Reddit post underscores the challenges that can arise when personal boundaries are tested and the dynamics of family relationships change dramatically. Derrick’s death left his ex-wife and son in a precarious financial situation, prompting the grandparents to lend a helping hand, and offering them temporary shelter and support.

At first, this gesture of generosity seemed to work well as the daughter-in-law (DIL) worked to rebuild her life and achieve financial independence. However, tensions arose when DIL’s personal decisions began to come up against the boundaries set by the grandmother, especially regarding her romantic relationships and their impact on the household environment, especially with her grandson present.

After a family disaster, there can be a significant change in household dynamics that can result in emotionally charged situations and difficult choices. Recently, a Reddit user posted a story that perfectly captures this kind of situation where personal boundaries, duty, and compassion are blurred.

Derrick, the child of a Reddit user, has died. The original poster (OP) found himself in a position to help his grandson and former daughter-in-law (DIL). After Derrick’s death, his ex-wife was left without the income she depended on, so the grandparents took in mother and son.

The purpose of this gesture of generosity was to provide DIL with temporary housing and stability while she worked towards her goal of becoming financially independent again.

“She was left with nothing after Derrick died. He wasn’t even covered by life insurance.”

The original poster (OP) detailed the poor financial condition of the DIL and stated that its funds were around $5,000. DIL and grandson used OP’s house as a shelter and a place to rebuild for two years. As a result of her efforts to support her family and continue her studies, DIL eventually obtained employment as a Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN), a major step toward independence.

Until DiL’s personal life took a turn that made the OP nervous, everything seemed to be going smoothly. “Until she graduated and got a job, everything was going smoothly. She found a new boyfriend. That’s okay. I totally accept that. She’s not actually my son’s widow. Their divorce is finalized. She’s grown too. She’s free.” to act as she pleases, but later she met another man and another,” the user said.

Although OP accepted DIL’s choice to manage her love life, she was concerned about the consequences of bringing home multiple partners, especially with a grandson living with them.

DIL and OP had an open discussion due to OP’s uneasiness with the circumstances. I just don’t want it at home. For the past two years, I have been hiding my romantic life from her and the child,” OP added.

DIL responded defiantly, stating that her personal life was none of OP’s business, despite OP’s efforts to keep the home discreet and polite.

After this conversation, the OP decided to invite the DIL to vacate before the end of the academic year. This choice drew criticism for being insensitive and judgmental. “When I spoke to her about it, she told me it was none of her business.

I agree too. At the end of this academic year, I asked her to move out,” the OP stated.

Even after making the final choice, the OP said, “I wish I could keep my grandchild and let her live her life.” In order to restore her personal space and ensure the best possible outcome for her grandson and his mother, the OP decided to ask the DIL to move out.

The OP began to question whether it was appropriate to move the daughter-in-law out of the house. When asked to comment on this delicate matter, the Reddit community mostly supported the OP.

“He’s taking advantage of your generosity.

You offered to live there because it gave your grandson a more stable environment. He can do whatever he wants in his own house. It’s time for her to go.

I hope it stays close by so you can watch your grandson. Someone wrote: “She’s going to need you.

Another person commented, “After your son passed away, you were extremely generous and compassionate in allowing your ex-daughter-in-law to live with you.

especially considering there was a bit of a gap in your relationship with her as they were previously divorced until his death. I guess she eventually got too comfortable, but she needs to realize that you are doing her a favor and that you ultimately decide who gets to enter your home! Sorry again for your loss.

After what she saw, was the grandmother right to order her grandson and daughter-in-law to leave her house? Do you believe that DIL made a mistake in bringing various individuals to her mother-in-law’s house and exposing them to her son? If you were in the OP’s position, how would you react?

Find out more about the woman who revealed her mother-in-law secretly watched her in bed. To cope, she decided to trap her father-in-law.

The situation described in the Reddit post highlights the complexities that can arise in a family after a tragedy. In this case, the Original Poster (OP) found themselves in a difficult position following the death of their son Derrick and the subsequent need to support their grandson and former daughter-in-law (DIL). OP’s gesture to provide temporary housing and stability to DIL and grandson was initially driven by compassion and a desire to help in a difficult time.

However, over time, tensions arose over DIL’s personal decisions and the impact they had on household dynamics. The OP’s displeasure with the DIL bringing several partners home, especially with the grandson present, led to a difficult conversation and ultimately the decision to ask the DIL to clear the house.

byu/Soft_Needleworker776 from discussion

byu/Soft_Needleworker776 from discussion

byu/Soft_Needleworker776 from discussion

Reaction from the Reddit community was mixed, with some supporting the OP’s decision as a necessary boundary-setting measure, while others criticized it as insensitive and judgmental. In the end, OP was faced with a difficult choice between maintaining her personal boundaries and ensuring the best outcome for their grandson and his mother.

In such emotionally charged situations, there are often no easy answers, and every decision carries its own consequences. It is clear that OP acted out of concern for their grandson’s well-being and a need to restore their own sense of personal space. Whether the decision was the right one depends on individual perspectives and the specific dynamics of the family involved.

Ultimately, it is most important that all parties involved find a way forward that promotes healing, respect, and the best interests of the child. As difficult as it can be, open communication, empathy and a willingness to work through challenges together can help families overcome even the most difficult circumstances.

Leave a Comment