Is it unjustified for me to ask my mother-in-law to depart from our wedding despite her covering the expenses?

A Reddit post detailing a woman’s conflict with her mother-in-law on her wedding day highlights the complexities of family relationships and issues with setting boundaries. A woman in her early twenties shares her journey through a strained relationship with her mother-in-law, who had a deep bond with her son’s ex-wife. Despite initial disapproval from her mother-in-law, over time the woman developed a bond with her that provided her with support during difficult times, such as the departure of her father-in-law and the birth of a child.

An older woman smiling while looking at another woman playing with the boy | Source: Pexels

However, tensions arose when the mother-in-law unexpectedly invited the ex-wife to the couple’s wedding without their consent. Despite the couple’s objections, the mother-in-law insisted on her participation, citing a financial contribution to the wedding. This led to a confrontation between the couple and the mother-in-law, resulting in the ex-wife leaving the ceremony. While the couple felt justified in enforcing their boundaries, they also expressed concern for their mother-in-law’s feelings and acknowledged her expectations for the wedding day.

The Reddit community weighed in on the situation, with some praising the couple for standing up for themselves and others questioning the mother-in-law’s motives. The incident prompts reflection on the importance of communication and mutual respect within family relationships, as well as the challenges of balancing personal boundaries with family responsibilities.

A coupe looking tense in the street | Source: Pexels

Ultimately, the Reddit post challenges readers to consider how they would navigate similar situations, emphasizing the importance of enforcing boundaries while being aware of the impact on family dynamics. It serves as a reminder of the complexity of family relationships and the need for open communication and understanding to effectively navigate conflict.

After her mother-in-law tried to spoil her wedding day, the woman refused to back down.

But since MIL’s only possessions are her, her husband, and their child, she feels terrible for standing up.

A 28-year-old woman said on Reddit in 2021 that when she first started dating her 27-year-old son, her mother-in-law didn’t approve. The couple met four years after he split from his ex-wife, who his family still describes as “the love of his life”.

The original poster (OP) stated that her husband assured her that he doesn’t consider his ex to be his true love, so she’s not worried. Although “Mindy”, the first wife, did not want their toxic marriage to end, it led to their separation.

An elderly woman laughing with a young woman on the couch | Source: Pexels

The two were high school students who later married and divorced young. According to the OP, the reason MIL loved Mindy so much was because she forced her husband, who was struggling academically, to focus on his future. Their visit to different universities caused jealousy.

According to the OP, the former couple only married for convenience, which made matters worse when the husband decided to file for divorce at the age of 21. The OP continued:

“It was quite hard for me to get into his family, especially his mother, she was so, so, so in love with Mindy and adored her as her DIL.”

The OP revealed that Mindy’s mother-in-law was so attached to Mindy that she had a depressive episode after Mindy moved to another state to be away from her husband. However, the OP gradually grew closer to her MIL over time, albeit unfortunately.

A young couple carrying boxes while walking down the stairs | Source: Pexels

This was after the death of her father-in-law, whose loss devastated her mother-in-law. Since then, MIL has had a lot of help from the OP and her husband since she is the only child in the family. MIL was happy when OP and her husband welcomed their first son. She revealed:

“MIL has found a new lease on life because of him and even though we haven’t become a perfect family, we are close enough to let my MIL know she will never be alone again.”

After their baby was born, OP and her husband had to prioritize their needs after the global epidemic made things difficult financially. So they decided to use some of the couple’s savings and the money her FIL left her husband to buy their first house.

The groom and bride walking hand in hand at wedding venue | Source: Pexels

Moreover, they had planned to celebrate their official marriage with a small party, but MIL refused to allow them. Being proud of her son for raising his child well, she volunteered to cover the wedding expenses.

But because it wasn’t right, the OP and the father of her child declined MIL’s offer to help. However, she convinced them that, like her late husband, she would miss the wedding if they delayed the wedding too long.

The couple opted for a small, private wedding ceremony and even gave their mother-in-law some pointers on what to include and exclude from the ceremony. The couple was confused when MIL unexpectedly brought Mindy along as her plus-one on the wedding day.

Newlywed couple conversing while seated | Source: Pexels

They asked MIL who came and what was going on. Mindy was invited, she explained, because it was a “special day.” “My husband said yes, it was a special day for us and that Mindy had no business being there and would appreciate it if she left,” the OP stated.

Looking at her, her mother-in-law expressed her wish for Mindy to be removed from the ceremony. The mother-in-law then became angry and told the couple that since she had paid for the wedding, they could invite whoever they wanted.

However, the couple argued that Mindy is not just anyone and that it would be wrong of her to extend an invitation without informing them. She threatened to go if Mindy had to go, and the OP’s husband said, “By all means.”

It is interesting to note that MIL decided to stay behind but advised the couple to urge Mindy to go. OP’s wife was delighted to oblige and his mother was furious for the evening. The newlyweds offered to cover all or part of MIL’s expenses after the wedding, but she refused, saying the damage was already done.

Because they asked the matriarch of the family to leave, the OP and her husband feel a certain way about the events that transpired. Since the husband is her only child, they are aware that she has waited more for their wedding day and therefore they believe it was unfair to her.

Other Redditors, on the other hand, commented that the OP and her husband made a wise choice and that it was clearly a ruse by MIL to split them up. Someone commented that Mindy seemed weird that she even agreed to participate, especially considering how badly their marriage ended.

A young couple holding hands while sitting | Source: Pexels

Do you think the OP and her husband were right to ask his mother not to attend the wedding? If you were in the OP’s position, what would you do? Learn more about the father-in-law who got instant karma after mistreating his daughter-in-law.

A Reddit post recounting the ordeal of a woman who stood up to her mother-in-law at a wedding shows the complexity of family dynamics and the challenges of setting boundaries, especially during major life events. Despite her MIL’s initial disapproval and affection for her husband’s ex-wife, the woman gradually developed a relationship with her mother-in-law and provided her with support during difficult times. However, tensions arose when the MIL unexpectedly invited the ex-wife to the wedding without consulting the couple, prompting them to push their boundaries.

The couple’s decision to ask their mother-in-law to leave the wedding, despite her financial contribution, reflects their commitment to maintaining the integrity of their special day and asserting their autonomy as a couple. While they acknowledge the mother-in-law’s expectations of the wedding and the emotional significance attached to it, they prioritize their own comfort and boundaries in the face of unexpected circumstances.

byu/AITA_0000 from discussion
byu/AITA_0000 from discussion
byu/AITA_0000 from discussion

Reactions from fellow Redditors vary, with some praising the couple for standing their ground and others questioning the motives behind MIL’s actions. The incident prompts reflection on the complexity of family relationships and the importance of open communication and mutual respect in managing conflict and setting boundaries.

Finally, the Reddit post highlights the importance of enforcing boundaries, even in the face of family expectations or financial contributions. It encourages readers to consider their own approaches to similar situations and emphasizes the importance of prioritizing one’s own well-being and autonomy within family dynamics.

Leave a Comment